
Because of today's
holiday I thought it only fitting to make English muffins. Back in the day, ye olde English housewives used to bake English muffins on the hearth. Because of their proximity to the fire, bits of ash used to find its way on to the muffins and subsequently onto the hands and faces of hungry English kids and husbands. (Who apparently didn't care about a bit more carbon in their diet.) This phenomenon made English muffins a traditional breakfast and tea treat on Ash Wednesday and during Lent for many a pious Englishman. (At least until good ol'
Henry VIII came around and started makin' his own religion and all.)
Okay, I totally just made all of that up.
I really just wanted to see what making English muffins would be like. And it happens to be Ash Wednesday. But I had you there for a minute, didn't I?
Let's just get started.
I decided to use the recipe from my
Better Homes and Gardens New Baking Book. (Which, by the way, I got for free from my
Better Homes and Gardens ad rep when I was working in the advertising world, so many moons and children ago. The pay for that job was terrible, but sometimes the perks were good.)
I decided to do only half the recipe because who needs a dozen English muffins? (Plus, the cooking method is a little time intensive, as you'll see.)
I started by scalding 1C of milk, 2 TBL butter, 1/2 tsp salt, and 1 TBL sugar. I do it in the microwave because it's faster.

Then I added it to the 1 C of flour and 1 package of yeast that I had in my mixer.

Man, I
love my mixer. Seriously. If I were a pioneer, I'd totally be luggin' that thing across the plains because I use it all the time. Wait...
So then I mixed and scraped on medium speed for 30 seconds, and then on high speed for three minutes. This helps the gluten in the flour get all... gluteny. Whatever, this is an important step in most yeast breads. Don't skip it.

Then I added two more cups of flour, mixed it, and then used the mixer to knead the dough.

For reals, I LOVE my mixer. It makes making bread so much easier. If you don't have one, start dropping hints now. Mother's Day is only a few month's off. (My dad gave me mine for my birthday one year. That's right, I have the
world's best dad. And you don't.)
I let the machine do the work until the dough was nice and stiff but still elastic. (Again with the... glutenation.) At this point you're supposed to put the dough in a different, greased bowl. But I say, why create more dishes that you're gonna have to wash later? So this is what I do:

Yep, I let the dough stay on the hook while I spray the mixing bowl with cooking spray. (This is also a good way to tell if you've kneaded the dough enough; at least for stiff doughs.) Then I plopped the dough into the bowl and made sure that it got all nice and greasy.

Then I covered it and let it rise in a warm place for an hour.

After it had doubled in size I punched it down and let it rest for 10 minutes on a floured surface.

Now it was time to roll it out. Just a bit less than 1/2" thick. Pretty.

You're supposed to cut it out with a 4" biscuit cutter, but all I had was a 3.5" glass. Good enough for me!

At this point you're supposed to dip each side of the muffin in cornmeal. Mine were too dry, so the cornmeal wouldn't stick. No biggie - just brush each side with some water. Or, try my method, which is way faster and easier.

I'm all about being fast and easy. (That one's for you, roommate Stacey!)
So then I covered them with cornmeal...

and let them rise for another 30 minutes. (The huge one was just to see what a super-thick one would be like.)

In the meantime, I let Joshie play with the extra dough. Way fun, from a two year old's perspective! (Until I told him, no, he could not throw the dough into the living room. Because I'm mean like that.)

This is where English muffins get a little different. Instead of baking them in the oven, you cook them at 325 degrees on your electric skillet.

They cook for 25-30 minutes total, needing to be flipped every 5 minutes. (Making them a bit labor intensive, I think.)
They get all golden and crispy on the outside, and the cornmeal smells faintly of popcorn. Yum.

So they're cooked and golden and yummy and picture perfect.

Time to crack one of those bad boys open. But you don't use a knife - use a fork.

This makes all of those yummy nooks and crannies. Something's gotta soak up all the butter you're about to slather on.

At this point I must admit I tried the English muffin, plain. It was pretty good, but I could tell it would be pretty... plain... once they got cold. (Because let's be honest here, all hot, fresh bread is gonna taste pretty good.) Which is probably why even the recipe suggests toasting or broiling the halves. I think this is pretty interesting - usually toasting is saved for when bread gets old.
So I toasted a few halves.

And slathered on the aforementioned (and oh-so-important) butter. Mmm...

I mean seriously, doesn't this just make your mouth water?
Then it was time for the test: would the kids like it?

Yes, yes they would. With a little homemade strawberry/blueberry jam they were the perfect afternoon snack.
Final analysis: homemade English muffins are pretty tasty. But they're labor and time intensive, and in all honesty I think they're only slightly better than the storebought ones. Although if I made them a bit thicker I think they'd probably be a lot better than storebought ones. But will I be making them again? Meh. Probably not.